Theology Online | Christian Forums & More

  
Active Threads
Social Groups
Go Back   Theology Online | Christian Forums & More > Politics, Religion, And The Rest > . . . and The Rest
Reload this Page The TOL Debate Game
. . . and The Rest Discuss just about anything besides Politics and Religion! Discuss sports, pop culture, computers, videogames, welcome new members, wish someone a happy birthday. Or just chit chat!
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  (#31) Old
annabenedetti annabenedetti is offline
Silver Member
 annabenedetti's Avatar

 


Reputation:
annabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peers
annabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peers
June 7th, 2012, 10:56 AM

I like it, GO.

Except ... the pitcher plant could still have been planted by the weekend plant guy. The regular guy has been out for two months, and likely has been unable to do any ordering. The weekend guy takes it upon himself to order new plants, and makes a major mistake in plant selection.



   
Reply With Quote
  (#32) Old
Traditio Traditio is offline
Resident Platonist
 Traditio's Avatar

 

Reputation:
Traditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peers
June 7th, 2012, 11:00 AM

Problem 3: You aren't Mrs. Hutchenson?

A woman has just switched jobs, and with the change in jobs, she has changed healthcare providers. The new healthcare provider doesn't cover the doctor that she's been seeing; therefore, today, she is visiting a new doctor for the first time.

Amazingly, however, when she walks up to the counter, the secretary immediately seems to recognize her. Much to our woman's surprise, the secretary immediately pulls up a file and starts asking her about how her husband and children are doing.

But just as a security measure, of course, the secretary asks our protagonist what her date of birth is. Giving her date of birth, the secretary tells our woman to have a seat.

Even more amazingly, a few moments later, the nurse comes to take her to the doctor's office. Even the doctor seems to recognize her. He says: "Alright, Mrs. Hutchenson, are you ready for your checkup?"

"But I'm not Mrs. Hutchenson," she replies: "I'm Mrs. Pennywinkles!"

What's going on?





When a Man Lies He Murders
Some Part of the World
These Are the Pale Deaths Which
Men Miscall Their Lives
All this I Cannot Bear
to Witness Any Longer
Cannot the Kingdom of Salvation
Take Me Home

To Live is to Die, Metallica
   
Reply With Quote
  (#33) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 7th, 2012, 02:04 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
Problem 3: You aren't Mrs. Hutchenson?

A woman has just switched jobs, and with the change in jobs, she has changed healthcare providers. The new healthcare provider doesn't cover the doctor that she's been seeing; therefore, today, she is visiting a new doctor for the first time.

Amazingly, however, when she walks up to the counter, the secretary immediately seems to recognize her. Much to our woman's surprise, the secretary immediately pulls up a file and starts asking her about how her husband and children are doing.

But just as a security measure, of course, the secretary asks our protagonist what her date of birth is. Giving her date of birth, the secretary tells our woman to have a seat.

Even more amazingly, a few moments later, the nurse comes to take her to the doctor's office. Even the doctor seems to recognize her. He says: "Alright, Mrs. Hutchenson, are you ready for your checkup?"

"But I'm not Mrs. Hutchenson," she replies: "I'm Mrs. Pennywinkles!"

What's going on?
The problem is a case of mistaken identity, where a woman on her first visit to a Doctors office and is mistaken for another woman that has been there often enough to be recognized by sight.

Mrs. Pennywinkles looks very similar to Mrs. Hutchenson and even has the same date of birth.
This happens quite frequently for identical twins, but can sometimes happen for fraternal twins or other forms of multiple births.
Most people with an identical twin know about it, but sometimes the twins are separated early enough that they do not remember each other, and some of the twins that are separated are not told about their identical twin.

So, the first solution to come to mind is that Mrs. Pennywinkles has an identical twin, but was separated from her twin at an early age and the people that raised her did not tell her about her twin.

It is similar to what happened in this news story:
Separated at birth, Indonesian twins meet in Sweden





Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
  (#34) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 7th, 2012, 02:18 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by annabenedetti View Post
I like it, GO.

Except ... the pitcher plant could still have been planted by the weekend plant guy. The regular guy has been out for two months, and likely has been unable to do any ordering. The weekend guy takes it upon himself to order new plants, and makes a major mistake in plant selection.
Yes, that could have happened, as long as the plants ordered arrived already mature enough to trap insects, but when I worked as a landscaping assistant, the plants ordered by the landscaper were all young plants that required some time to mature. Giving the plants enough time to mature before they started catching insects is the main reason I thought that the plants had been ordered and planted prior to the veteran plant guy going in for surgery, but it was so obvious to me that I forgot to mention it.





Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
  (#35) Old
aCultureWarrior aCultureWarrior is offline
LIFETIME MEMBER
 aCultureWarrior's Avatar

 

Reputation:
aCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peersaCultureWarrior is well respected by his peers
June 8th, 2012, 07:59 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
Yes. That's why I didn't mention forensics.

Just play the game, ACW.
Thank you for the personal invitation Traditio, as I wouldn't have wandered into this thread without your invitation.

Do me a favor and don't send me anymore invitations if you're going to continue to be a snippy little college edjumacated Marxist.





"Smoking cannabis makes people more intelligent."

Dope smoker and attempted Presidential assassin Oscar Romero Ortega-Hernandez
   
Reply With Quote
  (#36) Old
Traditio Traditio is offline
Resident Platonist
 Traditio's Avatar

 

Reputation:
Traditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peers
June 8th, 2012, 12:04 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by genuineoriginal View Post
The problem is a case of mistaken identity, where a woman on her first visit to a Doctors office and is mistaken for another woman that has been there often enough to be recognized by sight.

Mrs. Pennywinkles looks very similar to Mrs. Hutchenson and even has the same date of birth.
This happens quite frequently for identical twins, but can sometimes happen for fraternal twins or other forms of multiple births.
Most people with an identical twin know about it, but sometimes the twins are separated early enough that they do not remember each other, and some of the twins that are separated are not told about their identical twin.

So, the first solution to come to mind is that Mrs. Pennywinkles has an identical twin, but was separated from her twin at an early age and the people that raised her did not tell her about her twin.

It is similar to what happened in this news story:
Separated at birth, Indonesian twins meet in Sweden
GO, either my problems are too easy or you are more clever than I thought you to be.





When a Man Lies He Murders
Some Part of the World
These Are the Pale Deaths Which
Men Miscall Their Lives
All this I Cannot Bear
to Witness Any Longer
Cannot the Kingdom of Salvation
Take Me Home

To Live is to Die, Metallica
   
Reply With Quote
  (#37) Old
annabenedetti annabenedetti is offline
Silver Member
 annabenedetti's Avatar

 


Reputation:
annabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peers
annabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peersannabenedetti is well respected by his peers
June 8th, 2012, 12:11 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
GO, either my problems are too easy or you are more clever than I thought you to be.
Your problems are too easy - AND - GO is more clever than you thought.




   
Reply With Quote
  (#38) Old
Tambora Tambora is offline
Let's roll!
 Tambora's Avatar

 



Reputation:
Tambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peers
Tambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peers
June 8th, 2012, 02:51 PM

Quote:
"But I'm not Mrs. Hutchenson," she replies: "I'm Mrs. Pennywinkles!"
She divorced Hutchenson and married Pennywinkles.
Which is why she had to change jobs and health benefits, as she used to work for her former husband, and her new husband did not like that.






   
Reply With Quote
  (#39) Old
Quincy Quincy is offline
Silver Member
 Quincy's Avatar

 

Reputation:
Quincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peers
Quincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peersQuincy is well respected by his peers
June 8th, 2012, 06:35 PM

Sorry I missed out on a reply to the first problem Traditio but I'm glad to see people participating in this. I'll try to chime in on the next topic .





this post was brought to you by the letter Q
   
Reply With Quote
  (#40) Old
Traditio Traditio is offline
Resident Platonist
 Traditio's Avatar

 

Reputation:
Traditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peersTraditio is well respected by his peers
June 9th, 2012, 08:02 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tambora View Post
She divorced Hutchenson and married Pennywinkles.
Which is why she had to change jobs and health benefits, as she used to work for her former husband, and her new husband did not like that.
Against Tambora: the lady in question clearly is surprised at all the apparent recognition she is receiving. Were it but a change in last names, she would have expected to be recognized.





When a Man Lies He Murders
Some Part of the World
These Are the Pale Deaths Which
Men Miscall Their Lives
All this I Cannot Bear
to Witness Any Longer
Cannot the Kingdom of Salvation
Take Me Home

To Live is to Die, Metallica
   
Reply With Quote
  (#41) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 9th, 2012, 11:04 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by genuineoriginal View Post
The problem is a case of mistaken identity, where a woman on her first visit to a Doctors office and is mistaken for another woman that has been there often enough to be recognized by sight.

Mrs. Pennywinkles looks very similar to Mrs. Hutchenson and even has the same date of birth.
This happens quite frequently for identical twins, but can sometimes happen for fraternal twins or other forms of multiple births.
Most people with an identical twin know about it, but sometimes the twins are separated early enough that they do not remember each other, and some of the twins that are separated are not told about their identical twin.

So, the first solution to come to mind is that Mrs. Pennywinkles has an identical twin, but was separated from her twin at an early age and the people that raised her did not tell her about her twin.

It is similar to what happened in this news story:
Separated at birth, Indonesian twins meet in Sweden
Against genuineoriginal:
This answer does not work because of the way that doctor's offices are run. The secretary at the doctor's office has a list of the people sheduled for appointments each day, and Mrs. Hutchenson was scheduled for a checkup for the day and time that Mrs. Pennywinkles showed up for an appointment. There is no indication in the problem that two identical looking people showed up for appointments at the same time, so Mrs. Pennywinkles must be there for Mrs. Hutchenson's appointment.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
Problem 3: You aren't Mrs. Hutchenson?

A woman has just switched jobs, and with the change in jobs, she has changed healthcare providers. The new healthcare provider doesn't cover the doctor that she's been seeing; therefore, today, she is visiting a new doctor for the first time.

Amazingly, however, when she walks up to the counter, the secretary immediately seems to recognize her. Much to our woman's surprise, the secretary immediately pulls up a file and starts asking her about how her husband and children are doing.

But just as a security measure, of course, the secretary asks our protagonist what her date of birth is. Giving her date of birth, the secretary tells our woman to have a seat.

Even more amazingly, a few moments later, the nurse comes to take her to the doctor's office. Even the doctor seems to recognize her. He says: "Alright, Mrs. Hutchenson, are you ready for your checkup?"

"But I'm not Mrs. Hutchenson," she replies: "I'm Mrs. Pennywinkles!"

What's going on?
The problem is about a woman who doesn't remember her name and recent events.

Mrs. Hutchenson had to switch doctors because of a change in health insurance. In order to see the new doctor, she had to sign a release of information so her file could be obtained from the previous doctor. The medical file contains her picture, which turned out to be a good enough likeness of her that she was instantly recognizable to both the secretary who was looking at her file and the doctor who had looked at it earlier to prepare for the meeting. Additionally, the secretary recognized Mrs. Hutchenson from their prior meeting when Mrs. Hutchenson came in to make the appointment for the checkup and fill out the release of information form, and the two probably talked about Mrs. Hutchenson's husband and children during their conversation at that meeting.

Mrs. Hutchenson is most likely suffering from a case of amnesia or early onset Alzheimer's, which can develop in people who are in their 30s or 40s. Mrs. Hutchenson is able to clearly remember her early life when she was Mrs. Pennywinkles, but is not able to clearly remember her later life when she is married to Mr. Hutchenson. The doctor's visit was a checkup on an existing condition by a new doctor.





Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
  (#42) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 9th, 2012, 11:06 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by annabenedetti View Post
Your problems are too easy - AND - GO is more clever than you thought.






Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
  (#43) Old
Tambora Tambora is offline
Let's roll!
 Tambora's Avatar

 



Reputation:
Tambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peers
Tambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peersTambora is well respected by his peers
June 9th, 2012, 11:21 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
Against Tambora: the lady in question clearly is surprised at all the apparent recognition she is receiving. Were it but a change in last names, she would have expected to be recognized.
Good catch!






   
Reply With Quote
  (#44) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 9th, 2012, 11:28 AM

Mrs. Pennywinkle
Mrs. Pennywinkle is one of the babysitters who volunteered to take care of Bart, Lisa and Maggie. for marge and homer She declined to take the job after Homer rudely yanked on her hair on the basis of thinking she was a man after seeing the film Mrs. Doubtfire.


If she is Mrs. Pennywinkle, I'm Homer Simpson.





Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
  (#45) Old
genuineoriginal genuineoriginal is offline
TOL Subscriber
 genuineoriginal's Avatar

 

Reputation:
genuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peersgenuineoriginal is well respected by his peers
June 11th, 2012, 06:17 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Traditio View Post
GO, either my problems are too easy or you are more clever than I thought you to be.

The solution was not as simple as it looked to be at first.





Learn to read what is written.
   
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com
Copyright ©1997-2012 TheologyOnLine

Logos Bible Study Software Up to 15% OFF FOR THEOLOGYONLINE MEMBERS! Study twice, post once.
Logos Bible Software —take your Bible study to the next level.