Originally Posted by chair
Ever since you started this thread I've been wondering about the contrast between your extremely rigorous approach to Newton's calculations (by the way, I did go over them in the end- curiosity got the better of me) and the statement above.
Its not that you read my work, which in the end may have little importance;
its the fact that you were compelled to check
and that you admitted you did this openly,
that causes my opinion of you to have jumped upward an order of magnitude at least.
I bow to your magnanimity and scientific discipline.
Can you explain why the difference in approach?
R & R vs. serious work.