Recent content by Derf

  1. Derf

    God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

    It is only insane, irrational, and ridiculous if @way 2 go is to be held accountable for "his" choices, because they weren't really his.
  2. Derf

    God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

    Ok, I see what you are saying. If God responds to something we do, then His response is one of His works, and He had to have known what we would do in order to respond in the preplanned way. It seems to me that you still have the problem of knowing what, say, "Bob" will do before he exists...
  3. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    I own chickens. The roosters will mate with whichever hen they can catch. If a new rooster comes, he will try to mate with the hens, even if the previous rooster is still there. This would be called rape if it happened with humans instead of chickens. So, if God didn't exist, and we acted like...
  4. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    Not to mention the children adopted or surrogated into them are hurt.
  5. Derf

    God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

    Ok, you've presented a good example of a type of work that God is doing that He would be happy to claim as His own. But "exhaustive" foreknowledge would also include the things that are an abomination to God, or things that blaspheme His name. Your verse would characterize those things also as...
  6. Derf

    Confessions of a Reluctant Catholic

    I don't think ink on paper can either suppose or presuppose anything. Rather scripture describes and we come to scripture with our own presuppositions, hopefully to either confirm or deny them. Not exactly, but it does describe in such a way to leave the trinity as the only logical choice. Or...
  7. Derf

    Confessions of a Reluctant Catholic

    And, Paul's recitation of the Lord's Supper in 1Cor 11 was not the first they had heard of it. He said in vs 23: For I received from the Lord **what I also delivered to you**, that the Lord Jesus on the night when he was betrayed took bread...
  8. Derf

    God's Exhaustive Foreknowledge

    @way 2 go Your answer: (Acts 15:18) All His works are known to God from eternity. You seem to be saying that God knows all facts about the future including all choices every one will ever make because they are all "God's works." Is that what you believe?
  9. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    But one of the main points of argument around here is the definition of God, whether He is omnipresent or not, or omniscient or not. Whether He decrees all things or not. Whether He is impassible and immutable. Sure. He gives us much more than life. He gives us rationality, as @Clete has...
  10. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    But the problem is that we have as hard a time defining "life" as we have defining God. He has given us some insight into His attributes and His character, some of which we debate vociferously. So, too, the definition of life is debated. We even say that when we die (which would normally be...
  11. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    Yes, He is: Hebrews 6:13. “For when God made promise to Abraham, because he could swear by no greater, he sware by himself,”
  12. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    But He gives His standard verbally, and if there's some way that He can be said not to be iniquitous, then He would have to be consistent with the standard He has given in words, or He would be a divided kingdom that cannot stand. This is the argument against higher Calvinism that says God WANTS...
  13. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    You just cited a verse that says how morality applies to the perfect Creator God. He is "without iniquity". How can anyone be judged "without iniquity" unless a moral standard is applied to him?
  14. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    Yes. And that means that there is a code of morality Abraham was applying to God. It means that if God took the lives of the "righteous" along with the wicked, it would be immoral in Abraham's view. Whether Abraham was correct about that assertion is not provided in the passage, but God agreed...
  15. Derf

    What Is Morality, and is it Absolute?

    I'll accept that definition, but it requires understanding of what "moral" means, which is the topic of the thread. But if "our" is applied to God, then it ceases to be murder, even if it is innocent blood? Why do you think this? Then it would be impossible for us to shed innocent blood for...
Top